50 paranormal romance story starters
The 50 paranormal romance story starters are love stories with a supernatural twist never seem to go out of style. Whether it’s vampires, werewolves, witches, fairies, or ghosts, paranormal romance offers an exciting escape into imaginative worlds where the magical and mundane collide.
In this post, I’ll be sharing 50 paranormal romance story starters to spark your imagination and get those creative juices flowing. With unpredictable plots bringing together mortal beings and mesmerizing immortal creatures, these story ideas range from enchanting to chilling.
You’ll find star-crossed soulmates, time-traveling visions, dormant magical powers, ancestors’ curses, psychic connections, mythical folklore, and so much more. The story starters explore captivating themes of destiny, eternal love, danger, mystery, and breaking free from societies stuck out of time.
So get ready to enter realms filled with supernatural seduction and everlasting passion. Whether you’re looking for your next read or aspire to write your own bewitching tale of otherworldly romance, let these fifty paranormal prompts set your imagination ablaze. The mystical adventures await…
50 paranormal romance story starters
- After moving to a new town, a teenage girl meets a mysterious boy who only appears on nights with a full moon, making her suspect he’s a werewolf.
- A young nurse is assigned to care for a reclusive patient in his decrepit Gothic mansion and falls for her pale, tormented patient before exposing his dark vampiric secret.
- On the run after escaping an elite supernatural hunting society, a compassionate vampire takes refuge in a small town and finds salvation in the arms of a widowed mother unaware of his true otherworldly identity.
- A wizard sworn to protect the divide between magical and mortal realms brings his down-to-earth twin brother to a mystical dimension to search for a missing royal heir, only to have him fall for the new rulers’ mischievous princess.
- After moving to New Orleans, a fledgling witch discovers her family descends from ancient druid bloodlines when she awakens a playful, flirtatious spirit bound to make five generations of female descendants fall in love with him.
- A bashful bookshop owner’s first big online sale happens to be a rare spellbook sold to a flirty warlock intent on winning her heart with magical courtship rituals before revealing his supernatural identity.
- A logical skeptic visiting New Orleans on business suddenly finds she can see ghosts after a psychic’s predictions about her one true love’s imminent arrival start coming true through supernatural coincidence and charm.
- After a geomagnetic storm hits, all technology stops working in a small Kansas town except a woman’s e-reader filled with steamy paranormal romances which strangely inspire her cattle rancher neighbor to court her by manifesting the fictional magic powers.
- A plus-sized grad student flustered by her cute new professor’s interest in her thesis on fairy folklore discovers mystic connections between them started when he accidentally gave his heart to the fairy queen after a magical childhood encounter.
- A cynical witch exiled to the mortal world has her paranormal dating prospects revived by a divorcee unaware he harbors dormant wizard genes activated by her magical presence.
- A gentle young man’s repeated dreams of a soulful beauty trapped in a Celtic monastery library turn out to be time-jumping visions showing his soulmate’s past life until he discovers her current incarnation restoring books in the ruins.
- Captured by a covert military unit investigating supernatural phenomena, a good-natured troll taps telepathic links with the general’s daughter to make his daring escape back to his forest sanctuary with the help of her awakening psychic powers.
- An angel tasked with granting miracles to revive townspeople’s lost faith finds himself distracted from his duties by his growing earthly attachment and forbidden romance with the town’s lonely skeptic – a brilliant writer researching the strange phenomenon for her next book.
- A family of ancient shapeshifters bound to protect sacred Yosemite grounds clash with National Park founders over land stewardship until firefighting efforts awaken forbidden attraction between a young ranger and the alpha’s strong-willed daughter.
- A mermaid princess longing for adventure is captured by a dashing pirate captain oblivious that she has been sent by her father to sabotage his ship, only to fall desperately in love after spending weeks together at sea.
- After moving to Salem, a Wiccan practitioner skeptic of her family’s diaspora from the famous witch trials investigates the sudden activity of her long dormant powers and starts uncovering time-jumping connections to her past life.
- A Gen Z social media influencer renting a cottage to get away from it all discovers the remote town seems trapped in the 1950s because a resident witch’s stopped time spell has kept residents from aging to preserve its picturesque charm and her long lost love.
- A fairy displaced from her magical realm takes human form during her exile, finding refuge with a widowed professor raising his niece and nephew who are the only ones that can see her true form with childlike wonder.
- A brooding Scottish lord harboring a family curse is forced to take a mail order bride who arrives from America revealing herself as a mystical healer descended from Celtic druids charged with lifting his torment.
- A young woman’s uncontrollable power to spread chaos and bad luck begins to subside after falling into the arms of a zen vampire turned monk who offers her shelter in his reclusive mountain temple.
- An immortal Muse unexpectedly begins receiving creative visions channeling iconic art and literary works after crossing paths with a mortal artist whose dormant soulmate link inspires her to revive his stagnant career at the cost of revealing her magical identity.
- A shy spinster inn owner must learn to harness her suppressed hedge witch gifts to lift curses plaguing her seaside village placed by a bitter sea hag in order to protect a shipwrecked navy lieutenant she nurses back to health.
- A rising pop star discovers her record producer is actually an undercover Eros whose gold-tipped love arrow missed its intended target and instead sparked forbidden supernatural attraction between them.
- A Wiccan botanist must summon the powers of an ancient Green Man muse associated with her family tree after a charming real estate mogul threatens the magical flora preserving her ancestral cottage said to be a portal to Avalon.
- A palm reader accustomed to fake fortune-telling for gullible clients discovers real psychic visions detailing the fate of a rugged sailor unaware he is her long lost soulmate returned after disappearing during a past life journey at sea.
- A magic bracelet that can glimpse soulmates’ past lives reveals a skeptical academic’s former incarnation as a healer burned at the stake is now the disembodied spirit of the flirty phantom haunting her inherited gothic manor.
- An animal psychic with a talent for resolving pet behavior issues discovers she can read the thoughts of a growly German shepherd newcomer in town who shifts into a temperamental yet magnetic werewolf alpha.
- A half-elf half human woman hiding her mixed magical heritage struggles with her growing feelings for the human king she’s magically bound to serve after he rescued her from exile despite laws forbidding royal relations with non-humans.
- After moving to Ireland to take up residence in her late grandmother’s mysterious cottage, a young writer discovers mythical creatures from Celtic lore appearing on the land are visible only to her and the handsome caretaker secretly tasked with keeping ancient legends hidden.
- A ladies’ book club begins experiencing romantic visions straight out of the steamy historical novels they read, only to discover the new member they welcomed is actually a mischievous love genie appearing as human through magical disguise.
- A vampire matchmaker helps her newly turned vampire client woo the reclusive mortal woman he has watched and protected for years, while keeping secret that the lonely man has been her soulmate across multiple past life incarnations going back centuries.
- A magic mirror revealing soulmates’ first meetings transports a shy comic-con fan into the action-packed medieval world of her cosplay crush where she has just ten days to win his heart before permanently swapping places with her sword-wielding fictional doppelganger.
- A wish-granting witch must decide if she should use forbidden magic to make her longtime friend fall in love with her when a love potion meant for a bachelorette party accidentally reveals his hidden romantic feelings for her.
- A rising actress discovers not only can she see people’s auras but her own mystical energy inadvertently makes mortal co-stars fall obsessed and madly in love with her—a power she struggles to keep underwraps to avoid endangering her career dreams.
- A wine critic skeptical of a legendary vineyard’s supposedly enchanted vines must protect its magical secret after she develops psychic ties with its passionate French owner that cause her to mentally experience euphoric visions from his compelling past.
- After moving to New Orleans, a pastry chef skeptical of psychics discovers she has clairvoyant baking talents allowing her to see details of guests’ love lives through the custom desserts she prepares, including the romantic fate of a charming skeptic determined to ask her out.
- Tasked with selling an Irish castle property, a real estate agent trying to convince the grumpy duke owner to move discovers not only is he her soulmate reincarnated across centuries but that she has latent healing talents triggered by his surly presence.
- A museum curator realizes she has the power to briefly send psychic visions transporting artists into the passionate moments of history’s greatest romances just before their iconic masterpieces were created after she accidentally activates a lover’s bracelet artifact.
- A geneticist conducting classified experiments splicing animal DNA discovers she can perceive human pheromones as intoxicating scents drawing her to a test subject later revealed to be a virile werewolf desperate to make her his true mate for life.
- A fortune tellernearing the end of her long lifespan with the power to glimpse patrons’ past lives finally discovers the reason for her eternal loneliness–her soulmate is a immortal vampire cursed to be ever-reborn yet forever trapped in time.
- A witch tasked with protecting the magical boundary between the human world and mystical Otherrealm discovers the new leader of the realm is her sociopathic ex who once stole her powers and will stop at nothing to make her his eternally suffering queen.
- After moving to a remote Scottish village, a young writer discovers the chief of the mysterious clan occupying the crumbling castle next door is her fated soulmate who has spent centuries using his supernatural longevity to selflessly defend the townspeople from unseen forces.
- A family of ancient Egyptian cat shifters sworn to protect the pharaoh’s treasures through the ages clash with a notorious tomb raider before realizing he is the reincarnation of the very pharaoh’s lover they once served.
- A shade bound to the haunted painting depicting her tragic death begins manipulating events to engineer another demise for the descendant whose body she must inhabit to experience physical pleasure again even if it means destroying the woman’s budding romance.
- The lone female werewolf of a pack seeking an alpha mate discovers the magnetically confident newcomer vying for her hand is actually a cunning vampire infiltrator with his own reasons for gaining her people’s trust through beguiling seduction.
- A witch inaccurately predicted to fall for the conceited playboy warlock instead finds herself experiencing prophetic signs of fated love after crossing paths with his introverted mortal best friend unaware he harbors dormant sorcerer blood.
- A demigod offspring of a Norse god and human raised in secrecy among Vikings setting out to claim new lands discovers one Shield Maiden in the chieftain’s war band is actually the human incarnation of her divine father’s prophesied one true valkyrie soulmate.
- Merging her soul with a dying girl in a past life, a spirit demonness promised her human lover she’d return once his current incarnation was ready to accept her supernatural form, but his modern personality lacks the dangerous edge once irresistible to her.
- Researching local ghost stories, a journalist skeptic spends the night locked inside a haunted English manor and discovers the spirits plaguing grieving widows are actually lustful incubi who mysteriously view her as their prophesied queen.
- A alpha werewolf sworn to protect humans finds his beliefs challenged when he captures a dark elf assassin sent to kill his human soulmate who he discovers is secretly a dormant sorceress awakened by their forbidden union.
We hope you enjoyed our paranormal romance story starters and we hope they inspired you to write something great. If they did please share some in the comments. We are happy to hear from you. We also have many other writing prompts and story starters on our site. You may find them helpful.