50 True Crime writing prompts

50 True Crime writing prompts

Do you love true crime? Here are 50 True Crime writing prompts that can help you turn your hobby into a passion. Write the next great crime novel with these 50 true crime sounding writing prompts. (Writing prompts are not real crimes, no one was harmed during the making of this list). These true crime prompts can get you writing with ideas that sound like they were ripped right from the headlines!

True crime continues captivating masses as one of the most popular genres, with avid fans endlessly speculating on unsolved mysteries, criminal psychology, and masterful investigative work unfolding in news reports and headlines. Audiences love dissecting enigmatic cold cases, theorizing serial killer motives, and imagining how they’d outmaneuver corrupt officials evading justice.

Now arrives an imaginative blog series fusing this prevalent fascination with suspenseful true crime tales and creative writing. Readers can expect fictional vignettes and character studies directly inspired by the most bold, shocking and macabre cases occupying our national obsession.

Over 50 riveting posts, expect to encounter short stories featuring secret smuggling rings infiltrated by tenacious journalists, wrongly imprisoned citizens unraveling vindictive conspiracies after daring prison escapes, detectives decoding visual clues left by elusive murderous siblings spreading fear, and ordinary individuals pulled into dangerous criminal webs while investigating deceased loved ones’ hidden lies.

Combining a lifelong love of suspense literature with more recent true crime intrigue, this blog presents fascinating “what if” spins on the ever-intriguing true crime stories currently dominating headlines and feeding society’s undying macabre curiosity.

Here are 50 True Crime writing prompts

1. Even forensic experts were baffled – how did an intruder bypass advanced security systems to steal priceless artifacts without leaving a trace? His daring heist would come to be known as The Case of the Ghost Thief.
2. Shannon thought she found happily ever after – until private investigators uncovered her new husband’s murderous past lives hidden under aliases. She was now the hunted.
3. Jimmy always skirted the rules growing up – but law enforcement must finally bring his car theft ring screeching to a halt before more hot vehicles vanish.
4. They thought moving to an elite gated community guaranteed protection. That belief shattered violently the night a serial squatter left a trail of bodies inside their barricaded paradise. Safety was now the illusion…danger the new reality.
5. Emotions running fiery-hot – that was Chief Inspector Davis’s initial theory when a beloved community elder and her family wound up slain in a remote cabin amid the ashes. But science would soon reveal cold calculations behind the vengeance.
6. If walls could talk inside Cell Block D. What the guards can’t contain and the razor wire fences can’t cage are the secret worlds unfolding through whispers and stashed notes between unlikely allies. The true power dwells inside…
7. “We were the last ones to see little Susie alive…” Three witnesses hold clues that don’t line up when piecing together the 10-year old’s final joyful afternoon – before her devastating fate just 10 miles outside town.
8. They assumed reports were exaggerated – until their humanitarian mission encountered the child trafficking ring thriving right under the world’s nose. Now ensuring justice requires playing chess against ruthless warlords and corrupted politicians.
9. When the mysterious copper box appeared atop the police chief’s desk sealed in wax imprinted with a serpent insignia, he knew this case would brand his career – and likely claim lives before shocking town secrets finally crawled into the light.
10. Criminal masterminds often slip up with small oversights. So when Jake noticed the pharmacy robber’s odd accent slipped slightly, detecting the imposter became his lone chance to solve the undiscovered crime network hiding statewide.
11. Even behind the fortress of Sing Sing’s reinforced walls, ruby red secrets passed illicitly through inmates’ cunning hands held the power to silence snitches and elevate new criminal royalty – if ever whispered to cunning ears on the outside.
12. They were the most savage contract killers Chicago ever produced – until two detectives decode the murderous siblings’ visual calling card and broadcast their identities citywide under a simple symbol printed on matchboxes and tucked into victims’ pockets.
13. My journalism mentor once said chasing truth often demands unlawful maneuvers. But infiltrating the smuggling ring as an undercover boat hand to uncover their offshore operations proves my breaking point might meet the ocean floor instead.
14. As lead prosecutor, I must sway the suspicious jury to convict the charismatic, cutthroat Wall Street tycoon guilty of swindling millions from innocent pensioners. Little do they know we shared steamy history I’ve done everything to bury – but if it guarantees he finally pays…
15. Bumping off low-level street dealers was child’s play for Vincent’s upstart cartel. But rubbing out a top enforcer from the old-guard narcotics gang as a brazen power move would ignite all-out war across Miami – and likely redraw the city’s trafficking empire.
16. Master burglars live by simple rules – disable alarms, grab valuables quick, torch remnants that might identify. But when one veteran thief’s signature arson accelerant technique links a startling number of cold cases together, findings short-circuit investigator’s expectations.
17. We expecting riveting war stories interviewing Sylvia for our documentary on little-known heroes. While the plucky French freedom fighter certainly dazzled describing sabotaging Nazi supply lines, something about her cagey manner hinted at buried secrets too dark for celluloid.
18. As the trial’s ringmaster directing lawyer lines of inquiry, all knew DA Preston Brooks owned the courtroom – unless the defense somehow exposed his Achilles’ heel, an affliction even his savviest opponents currently remain unaware.
19. While the mysterious Poison Pen letters mailed to wealthy elite seemed relatively harmless at first, the handwritten death threats and secrets exposed about powerful figures suggested an elaborate web of vengeance – with citywide implications if culprit isn’t quickly collared.
20. They considered clever Checkbox Carl’s suburban spree an anomalous blip explaining the rash of burglaries targeting only worthy 18th century maps and globes worth millions as strange midlife crisis. But when a body surfaced matching his contexts, authorities shifted focus to more sinister theories.
21. Investigators traced the assassin’s origins when scans of his forged passports and covert communications revealed subtle regional spelling slip-ups, blowing his dangerous cover.
22. Jason’s prison escape plan counted on inmates providing distractions while he climbed fences. But overnight the convict code turned against outing snitches, leaving him solo against the spotlights.
23. While Pickpocketing Peggy’s hotel robberies proved harmless at first, when an elderly guest died from heart failure after the sneak thief invaded his room, her petty crimes turned deadly.
24. When “The Nun” kept showing up at mob hits wearing a habit over her signature red dress, police struggled tracing her identity through networks of lookouts ever covering this phantom’s lethal tracks.
25. They were the Bonnie and Clyde of cyber hacking – until global intelligence agencies decrypted the romantic partners’ secret online communications revealing the tools behind their digital heists.
26. Metro Crime’s finest joined forces following a tip declaring Sherlock’s Gentleman’s Club the perfect money laundering front. But bringing down its network of corrupt officials backing this secret den proved far more scandalous.
27. Mesmerized by her handsome biologist tutor since freshman year, star student Valerie stole rare toxins to spike his nagging wife’s gin and win her dream man – at least until suspicious scratches appeared on his arms.
28. As the tenacious small-town reporter investigating corrupt sheriff kickbacks, Sam never expected to be tied as a traitor and dumped unconscious into the bayou’s hungry jaws. This time the story itself might just devour him.
29. While the Cavendish Museum gala promised glitz showcasing Imperial Russia treasures, when assassins took patrons hostage demanding access to the Tsarina’s jeweled Faberge egg, the dream night soured into a tactical nightmare.
30. Tracking South Boston’s elusive smuggling gang leader “Lucky” felt near impossible given his triple bolt deadlocks and savvy camera maneuvers avoiding identification – until a bright drug sniffing police canine brought new tricks locating his hidden vault.
31. Even struggling as an ex-con and recovering addict, Nina’s counseling youth and penning cautionary addiction memoirs earned community respect – at least until criminology students correlated timing between her relapses and local pharmacy break-ins.
32. As lead archeologist unearthing ancient funerary treasures, Scarlett knew tomb raiders and black market dealers craved the priceless icons we discovered. But mummifying a traitorous dig team member as a brutal warning seemed extreme escalation.
33. While rural police wrote off the campground stalking incidents as harmless wildlife, Cryptozoology professor Artie Adler’s personal encounter suggested more sinister theories – perhaps explaining certain missing person cases spanning decades too…
34. Having trained vicious attack hounds for high profile clients wary of kidnappers and assassins, canine security consultant Bruno knew never to ask names or motives. But the bounty hunter currently tailing him indicates one guard dog may have switched allegiances, to dangerous personal cost.
35. As the reigning “Queen of Illegal Poker” in shady casino circles, lady luck let players assume Bianca’s wins came through chance alone. When bitter rivals with brutal reputations arrive to compete, however, her skill and charm may no longer protect the card empress.
36. Seeing another inmate sneak away into solitary always elicited curiosity what rules were violated. But when Charise recognized the visitor’s Italian loafers and signet pinky ring slipping inside, she knew Omerta’s code now demands her silence… under penalty of a more permanent isolation yet to come.
37. Investigators traced the assassin’s origins when scans of his forged passports and covert communications revealed subtle regional spelling slip-ups, blowing his dangerous cover.
38. While the Faceless Butcher evaded capture leaving no traces at gory slaughterhouse crime scenes, newly promoted Lt. Aaliyah Nasser discovers surveillance tapes showing a masked figure without gloves at the stainless steel sinks.
39. Coded ledger entries tied clean cut broker Elliott Hays to the lucrative art theft ring fencing stolen Warhols and Rembrandts via Swiss accounts. But could his surprise release on lack of hard evidence trigger a brazen museum robbery the very same night?
40. Turning rats usually reduced prison sentences substantially. But Norris failed to realize the sharp consequences after he snitched to the DA about the Aryan Clan’s gun running operation from behind bars – consequences now hunting him on the outside.
41. While the mysterious Poison Pen letters seemed relatively harmless at first, the handwritten death threats exposing dark secrets about powerful city figures suggested an elaborate insider campaign of coercion and vengeance brewing on anonymous elite typewriters.
42. When beloved Father Pat’s troubled past came to light after an exposé revealed the once admired clergyman fabricated his entire identity and background with the Church, investigators shift focus to unraveling what other altar boy secrets “Patrick” hides behind the holy cloth…
43. As lead prosecutor, all expected ADA Alexis to steamroll the violent empire of a ruthless drug kingpin whose muscle intimidated witnesses citywide into silence. Little did observers know she shared an intimate past with the golden-toothed dealer – one with photos to prove it.
44. While Metro PD anti-corruption squads wiretap organized crime fronts, under scrutiny Judge Terencesynchronizey Terence subtly communicates his sway over closeted city officials through coded dinner menus dropped at usual dead drop takeout joints. But can anyone decipher the orders?
45. When his daughter Allison disappears walking home from calculus tutorials, gut instincts tell pop psychologist Dr. Malcolm one of his unstable clients now targets his own family. As encrypted therapy session tapes trickle in taunting his powerlessness, outsmarting a diabolical psychopath becomes Malcolm’s only recourse to ever see Allie again.
46. No one expected Ferdinand to survive San Quentin much less keep his humanity given the horrors there. But salty convict poems he secretly scrawls beyond night sticks and constant shakedowns reveal how creating art and probing society’s gaps helps imprisoned minds find fleeting freedoms within confining walls.
47. While curating the soon-to-open National Museum of Organized Crime fulfilled Susan’s academic dreams, when a mysterious fedora-wearing patron keeps appearing alone on off hours obsessively gazing at exhibits featuring one display-encased tommy gun in particular, Susan realizes nightmare history shrouded in legend threatens her and possibly others bound by blood oath.
48. The framed photograph of their supposedly estranged mother arrives in nine year old Nina’s mailbox without explanation days after they buried their devastated father. But her name signed on the back in familiar feminine script suggests the deceased parent they knew was tangled in criminal deceit – pulling Nina into the dangerous web.
49. As lead detective haunted by the serial child killer somehow always vanishing moments before cops arrive to grisly suburban scenes over two states, Vinny notices through photos that one familiar middle school guidance counselor grayscale vehicle sits parked in multiple old crime scene backgrounds…
50. While intrepid student sleuth Kendra didn’t expect unmasking her prep school headmaster’s hidden DUI manslaughter past would catalyze his resignation, the threatening late night voicemail referencing her “meddlesome nature” suggests this Walter White shirt-wearing teacher harbored even darker secrets yet to unravel.

And so concludes our chilling collection of 50 true crime writing prompts pulled straight from the headlines. These fictional snippets aim to ignite your creative sparks and have you penning the next gripping thriller. With tales covering everything from alluring art heists to scandalous poison pen letters tormenting elites, this series allows your imagination to run wild theorizing “what-if” scenarios about the ever-intriguing world of crime. Use these creative launches to develop short stories, expand into novellas, or even inspire full-length novels filled with the intrigue and complex characters that make true crime tales irresistible page-turners. Wherever these prompts lead you, embrace your fascination with the genre and let the writing take hold until “The End” arrives. Just be careful if you find yourself identifying a little too closely with the criminal masterminds…We hope you enjoyed these writing prompts. If they were not your cup of tea, we have many other prompts on our site. Also, please leave us a comment, we’d love to hear from you! 

• Author
• Recent Posts

Richard

Richard Everywriter (pen name) is the founder of EveryWriter and a 25-year veteran of the publishing industry. With degrees in Writing, Journalism, Technology, and Education, Richard has dedicated two decades to teaching writing and literature while championing emerging voices through EveryWriter's platform. His work focuses on making literary analysis accessible to readers at all levels while preserving the rich heritage of American literature. Connect with Richard on Twitter  Bluesky Facebook or explore opportunities to share your own work on ourSubmissions page. For monthly insights on writing and publishing, subscribe to our Newsletter.

Latest posts by Richard (see all)

• Story Structure: How the Save the Cat! Method Can Transform Your Writing - April 23, 2025
• HALFWAY TO HALLOWEEN: 50 Words of Horror Contest - April 22, 2025
• How to Edit your poetry for beginners and beyond (with worksheet) - April 18, 2025